Staff Reports
A recent demand by French politician Raphaël Glucksmann to return the Statue of Liberty to France has ignited controversy on both sides of the Atlantic. Glucksmann, a member of the European Parliament and co-leader of the left-wing Place Publique party, argued that the United States no longer upholds the values of liberty and democracy that the statue represents. His remarks, delivered at a political rally, accused America of siding with tyrants and betraying its ideals. While his comments were met with applause from his supporters, they have drawn sharp criticism from U.S. officials and conservative voices.
The Statue of Liberty, gifted by France in 1886 to celebrate the centennial of American independence, has stood as a symbol of freedom and friendship between the two nations. Designed by Frédéric-Auguste Bartholdi and engineered by Gustave Eiffel, it represents shared ideals of liberty and democracy. However, Glucksmann’s assertion that America has “despised” these values under recent administrations has sparked backlash. White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt dismissed the demand as absurd, reminding France of America’s role in liberating them during World War II and asserting that the statue was U.S. government property.
This episode highlights broader frustrations among European leftists regarding shifts in American policy under President Trump. Critics like Glucksmann have taken issue with Trump’s foreign policy decisions, including reduced support for Ukraine and cuts to research funding. Yet such critiques overlook America’s continued leadership in global affairs and its enduring commitment to freedom. Conservative commentators have ridiculed Glucksmann’s remarks as political theater, pointing out that his rhetoric does little to address real issues facing Europe or strengthen transatlantic ties.
The notion of returning Lady Liberty is not only legally impossible but also an affront to American sovereignty and history. The statue has welcomed millions of immigrants to U.S. shores and remains a powerful emblem of hope and opportunity. Conservatives argue that attempts to undermine this legacy reflect a misguided focus on symbolism over substance. Instead of questioning America’s values, critics should consider how their nations can better embody principles of liberty and democracy.
Ultimately, this controversy underscores the resilience of American ideals in the face of criticism. The Statue of Liberty is more than a monument; it is a testament to the enduring partnership between France and America and a beacon for freedom-loving people worldwide. Calls to return it are not only impractical but fail to recognize its significance as a shared symbol of hope. As debates rage on, one thing remains clear: Lady Liberty isn’t going anywhere.
