The recent blowup between Douglas Murray and Dave Smith on Joe Rogan’s podcast exposed a raw divide in conservative ranks. Murray, a fearless defender of Western values, clashed with Smith, a comedian pushing radical anti-Israel claims. This wasn’t just a debate — it was a battle for the soul of the Right.
Murray stood firm for truth, calling out the far-left lies about Israel’s fight against Hamas terrorists. He warned that letting unqualified voices shape foreign policy is dangerous. Experience matters when lives are on the line. You wouldn’t let a plumber perform brain surgery — why let comedians dictate Middle East strategy?
Smith fired back, claiming “free speech” means anyone can rant about complex wars. He called Israel’s self-defense “genocide” — the same twisted language used by campus Marxists. It’s shocking to hear a Jewish voice parrot Hamas propaganda. Since when do conservatives side with jihadists over our closest ally?
Rogan initially let Smith’s lies slide, then later mocked Murray’s expertise. “Having a degree doesn’t make you right!” Rogan barked. True — but Murray actually visited Gaza, studied terror networks, and understands the stakes. Rogan platforms conspiracists masquerading as patriots.
The real issue? Murray’s right — media giants keep amplifying clueless shock jocks instead of serious thinkers. When Smith hides behind “I’m just a comedian!” after spreading hate, it proves Murray’s point. Democracy dies when facts become optional.
Smith’s betrayal stings deepest. As a Jew, he weaponizes Holocaust terms to bash Israel while terrorists burn babies. That’s not comedy — it’s collaboration with evil. True conservatives don’t throw allies under the bus for woke applause.
This feud shows the Right must unite behind leaders who’ve earned their stripes, not loudmouths chasing clicks. Murray’s lived experience vs. Smith’s hot takes isn’t a fair fight — it’s duty vs. decadence. America needs warriors, not clowns.
The takeaway? Conservatism can’t survive if we value memes over mission. Rogan’s platform should lift up those defending civilization, not tear them down. Murray’s courage lights the way — the rest of us must follow.