admin
A fiery debate exploded on Joe Rogan’s podcast this week between conservative writer Douglas Murray and comedian Dave Smith. The clash revealed deep cracks in today’s Right-wing movement — with Murray defending expertise and Smith slamming elitism.
Murray pushed back hard against claims he thinks only Ivy League grads should discuss serious issues. He clarified that while experts have failed regular Americans, real-world experience still matters. His decades reporting from war zones like Gaza, he argued, give him insight Smith’s comedy background can’t match.
Smith fired back, accusing Murray of “selective empathy” for Israel while ignoring Palestinian suffering. The libertarian comic insisted everyday Americans don’t need fancy degrees to see through government and media lies. Rogan mostly stayed quiet as tensions flared.
The heart of the fight? Murray says Rogan gives conspiracy theorists like Holocaust revisionists equal weight as historians. “You’re not ‘just asking questions’ when you platform frauds,” Murray charged. Smith shot back that gatekeeping speech helps the Left crush dissent.
Pro-Israel conservatives cheered Murray for standing strong. “Finally someone challenges Rogan’s both-sidesism on our airwaves!” tweeted GOP strategist Mike Davis. Anti-war libertarians rallied behind Smith, calling him a truth-teller unafraid to bash “neocon warmongers.”
Critics say this feud exposes a dangerous split. The establishment Right clings to credentials and foreign intervention. The populist wing trashes institutions and puts America first. Both sides agree the Left is the enemy — but can they unite before 2024?
Murray told Glenn Beck afterward that working-class Americans deserve voices who’ve actually walked the walk. “I don’t care about degrees,” he said. “I care about someone who’s been to the border, the trenches, the rubble — not just a studio.”
As the GOP fractures between think tanks and truck stops, this brawl proves one thing: The real America wants leaders who fight — not for accolades or clicks, but for truth. The question remains whether squabbling conservatives can deliver.
