Fox News host Greg Gutfeld and his colleagues are right to urge skepticism about the sudden flurry of ransom notes in the Nancy Guthrie disappearance; when the media smells a story, they too often amplify the drama before the facts are in. Conservatives know that our justice system and law enforcement deserve rigorous, not performative, scrutiny — and pundits who spot a possible ruse are doing the public a service by pushing for hard evidence rather than headlines.
According to reporting, 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie was last seen at her Tucson home on January 31 and law enforcement found blood at the scene that matched her DNA, prompting an active criminal investigation by local police and the FBI. This isn’t a soap-opera mystery for late-night hosts — it’s a real family facing real danger, and authorities must be empowered to pursue every credible lead while the public resists rumor.
Almost immediately after the disappearance, alleged ransom communications were circulated to local outlets and the demands reportedly escalated from multimillion-dollar figures to an even higher threat with tight deadlines — a pattern that smells suspiciously like opportunism to seasoned observers. When demands are posted to the public and deadlines become part of the spectacle, you have to ask whether the goal is extortion or attention, and whether anyone with law enforcement training can independently verify the claims.
Savannah Guthrie and her siblings have made emotional public pleas, saying plainly “we will pay” to get their mother home, but they’ve also demanded proof of life before engaging — the only rational stance any family would take in the face of potential fraudsters or copycats. The family’s anguish is real, and so is the temptation for predators to exploit a high-profile case; the media should stop amplifying unverified demands and let investigators work.
A former FBI official has openly questioned whether the ransom gambit is genuine or a brazen ruse, noting the lack of verifiable proof of life and the strange timing of escalating demands — skepticism that the rest of us should not mistake for callousness. Until law enforcement presents authenticated facts, Americans ought to demand clarity instead of being spoon-fed panic and speculation by outlets chasing clicks.
Patriots who value law and order should stand with the Guthrie family while insisting on due process and disciplined reporting. Let the FBI and local authorities follow leads, let legitimate evidence guide public conversation, and let decent Americans reject the circus that too often replaces sober justice in today’s media landscape.

