Politico published a dramatic exposé this week, releasing some 2,900 pages of private Telegram messages from leaders of state Young Republican groups that include the chilling line “I love Hitler” and other grotesque comments. The article paints a picture of a small circle of activists trading racist, antisemitic and violent jokes while holding leadership positions in the GOP’s youth infrastructure.
What made the story explode on social media wasn’t just crude language but talk of gas chambers, rape “jokes,” and slurs repeated hundreds of times across months of chat — material that rightly sickens decent Americans and demands accountability. These are not anonymous trolls hiding in a comment section; many participants are reported to have worked inside government or on campaigns and occupied state Young Republican leadership roles.
That said, anyone who cares about the health of the conservative movement should be furious about the selective, gleeful way legacy outlets like Politico circulate these leaks to maul an entire generation of activists. The report itself acknowledges apologies and denials, and at least one alleged participant has said portions of the chat may have been altered or taken out of context — claims the media wave has treated like inconvenient noise. Conservatives can and must condemn the vile language while still demanding a fair process, not a public execution.
Republican leadership’s response has been predictable and mixed: some have demanded resignations and swift consequences, while others — including Vice President J.D. Vance — urged Americans to keep perspective and called the participants “kids” making stupid jokes. That split matters politically; it reveals how badly our party needs a coherent strategy to police behavior without letting the swamp media destroy recruitment pipelines for future conservative leaders.
Make no mistake: private speech among adults that crosses lines must be punished appropriately when verified, but the rush-to-judgment and the weaponization of hacked or leaked messages sets a dangerous precedent. Politico’s decision to publish graphic excerpts and to frame the story as emblematic of the whole party risks turning a set of condemnable individuals into an indictment of every Republican young voter. Conservatives should insist on evidence, context and proportional consequences.
Some tangible fallout has already been reported — rescinded job offers, people losing positions, and state chapters under review — and that accountability should be applied where the reporting holds up. But patriotic Americans also need to push back hard when media narratives sweep the country like a moralistic forest fire that burns nuance and due process. We must clean house and build stronger standards internally, not simply kneel to the mob.
If the Republican Party intends to win in the long run, it will do two things at once: remove and discipline anyone who traffics in hate and violent fantasies, and rebuild youth outreach so decent, ambitious young conservatives aren’t driven away by a culture of cruelty or a press that treats every private mistake as political capital. That’s how you restore honor to the movement and protect America from a hostile media class determined to define us by our worst actors.