The Catholic Church has a new leader – Pope Leo XIV, formerly Cardinal Robert Prevost of Chicago. His election marks a historic first for America, but conservatives are watching closely to see if he’ll reverse the controversial direction of Pope Francis’s tenure. Early signs suggest a mix of continuity and potential change.
Leo XIV immediately called for peace in Gaza and Ukraine, echoing Francis’s global activism. He also pledged to continue “synodality” – Francis’s push for decentralized church governance that critics call dangerously progressive. Traditional Catholics groaned as the new pope praised his predecessor from the Vatican balcony.
But hope flickers for orthodox believers. Leo XIV helped remove Texas Bishop Joseph Strickland, a conservative firebrand who challenged Francis’s leftward drift. Now LifeSiteNews’ John-Henry Westin declares Strickland’s restoration would prove Leo XIV’s commitment to tradition. “He HAS to be restored,” Westin insists, calling this the papacy’s first real test.
The Chicago-born pontiff faces mounting pressure. Progressive cardinals expect more interfaith dialogue and climate action. Conservatives demand crackdowns on LGBT-affirming parishes and restoration of Latin Mass restrictions lifted under Francis. Leo XIV’s American pragmatism might seek middle ground, but both sides want decisive action.
Westin highlights worrying signs – Leo XIV backed Francis’s refugee policies and once criticized traditional liturgy. Yet optimism remains. The new pope’s administrative skills could repair Vatican financial scandals neglected under Francis. His U.S. roots might foster stronger ties with American bishops resisting progressive mandates.
Crucial battles loom over priestly celibacy and women’s roles. Francis floated radical changes that terrified traditionalists. Early meetings suggest Leo XIV prefers slow reform over revolution, praising Francis’s “dialogue with modernity” while emphasizing “prudence.” This frustrates activists on both sides.
For now, conservatives cling to two hopes: Leo XIV’s reported personal piety and his age. At 69, he’s younger than recent popres, potentially leading decades-long course corrections. If he resists European cardinals’ liberalism and empowers Global South churches, the Francis era could fade into a more orthodox chapter.
America’s pope now walks a razor’s edge. Will he heal the Church’s divisions or deepen them? Traditional Catholics pray his American spirit reignites biblical values in a faith they believe has lost its way. The world watches as this unexpected pontiff begins his high-stakes balancing act.