Staff Reports
When it comes to holiday movies, few discussions are as heated and entertaining as the debate over whether “Die Hard” is a Christmas movie or just an action flick set during the holiday season. The drama kicks up like a snowstorm every year as fans of the film weigh in on why this Bruce Willis classic deserves a seat at the table—right next to “Elf.” Let’s unpack this festive struggle and see if we can find some common ground.
First off, many proponents of the “Die Hard is a Christmas movie” argument start by highlighting the setting. The film takes place on Christmas Eve, a time traditionally associated with cheer, family gatherings, and—of course—Christmas parties. The movie opens with scenes of holiday decorations, festive music, and a palpable buzz of excitement as people get ready to celebrate. In the world of cinema, a movie set during this special time often qualifies as a holiday movie. So, if a film has tinsel, trees, and jingle bells, shouldn’t it be tagged as a Christmas classic?
Another important aspect of this debate is the theme of joy during the holiday season. While some people might think of joy purely in terms of cozy family gatherings or heartwarming traditions, others associate it with action, adventure, and a little bit of chaos—like trying to rescue loved ones from terrorists in a high-rise building. It seems joy can manifest in many ways, and humorously enough, for some, that includes explosions and nail-biting scenes. Yet, isn’t that the magic of Christmas? There’s something for everyone in the mix of emotions, and “Die Hard” offers a thrilling respite from more traditional fare.
And then there’s the character of John McClane. He might not be wearing a Santa suit or delivering gifts, but he’s ultimately fighting for love and family. Forging connections amidst the chaos, he proves that even in a hostage situation, the spirit of togetherness and perseverance shines through. Isn’t that what the holidays are all about? Watching a man leap from one floor of a building to another to save his wife might not be what Hallmark had in mind, but the underlying message of love and sacrifice ties right into the holiday sentiments.
Now let’s not forget about classic comedies like “Elf.” While Buddy the Elf offers a goofy portrayal of the holiday spirit with laughter and heart, some argue that “Die Hard” keeps the excitement alive with its mix of drama and humor. Maybe the truth is that holiday movies come in all shapes and sizes. Why can’t both “Elf” and “Die Hard” coexist in the Christmas pantheon? After all, variety is the spice of life—especially during the holiday season!
So where do we land on this slippery, ice-coated debate? According to a recent Talker Research poll conducted for Newsweek, 45 percent of Americans do not consider “Die Hard” a Christmas movie, while only 38 percent affirm that it is1. Perhaps the answer lies in one simple truth: it doesn’t matter whether “Die Hard” is labeled a Christmas movie or not. What matters is that it brings people together for spirited debates while sharing popcorn and holiday cheer. Whether it’s families gathering around to watch the latest rom-com or friends bickering over the definition of holiday magic, these discussions keep the spirit alive and may just get everyone in the mood for festive celebrations. Regardless of its classification, “Die Hard” will remain in the hearts of many as an unexpected yet thrilling companion to the Christmas season.
