in

Florida AG James Uthmeier Says Bump‑Stock Ban Unconstitutional

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier just shook up the debate over bump stocks by issuing a formal legal opinion saying the state’s 2018 bump‑stock ban (Section 790.222) is unconstitutional. He also announced his office will not defend convictions under that law on appeal. It’s a big shove toward protecting the Second Amendment — even if the statute still sits on the books.

What the AG actually said about the bump stock ban

Uthmeier’s opinion says the law’s broad wording — banning “conversion kits, tools, accessories, or devices” that increase a firearm’s rate of fire — sweeps too wide and runs into the Second Amendment. The opinion leans on the Supreme Court ruling in Garland v. Cargill and says Florida’s statute, as written, could bar lawful accessories that fall under the plain text of the Constitution. That’s the legal backbone for the decision not to defend convictions under §790.222 in appeals.

Why this matters for enforcement and the courts

To be clear: the law is still written into Florida statutes. Only the Legislature can repeal it, or a court can strike it down. But the AG’s office will not mount appellate defenses of convictions under the bump‑stock ban. That changes the practical math for prosecutions — local state attorneys can still charge people, but they may face weaker backing at the appellate level. Defendants now have a clearer path to press constitutional challenges, and judges will get to sort this out without the state’s chief lawyer arguing for the statute.

Politics, precedent, and the next steps

Governor Ron DeSantis praised the move, and gun‑rights groups hailed the opinion as a commonsense win for the Constitution. Gun‑control advocates are predictably unhappy. The reality is straightforward: an AG opinion doesn’t rewrite law, but it does set the state’s legal posture and invites litigation. If this is to be settled for good, either the Legislature must act to repeal the overbroad language in §790.222, or courts will be asked to follow the constitutional logic Uthmeier laid out. Until then, expect a patchwork of prosecutions and appeals across Florida.

This was the right call. Laws that trample on basic rights deserve a public re-examination, not long-term enforcement based on political panic. The Constitution shouldn’t change with every headline. If lawmakers truly care about consistent, fair law enforcement, they will fix the statute now — not wait for more confusion or chaotic prosecutions. If they don’t, the courts will, and that outcome could have been avoided.

Written by Staff Reports

Russell Brand Netflix "Doc" Features ACTRESSES Pretending They are Victims

Megyn Kelly: Netflix Used Actress to Fake Russell Brand Accuser

U.N. AI Report: Chatbots Fold, Risk Free Speech Policing

U.N. AI Report: Chatbots Fold, Risk Free Speech Policing